Home  Product and Services Guide  Stories, articles, and how-to's  Old-House-Friends Forums
"Dangers of Abrasive Cleaning" an Historic Preservation Brief December 1, 2008


How to clean rain lamp...
Member Sign In|Company Sign In





Dangers of Abrasive Cleaning
to Historic Buildings

Anne E. Grimmer
Dangers of Abrasive Cleaning

What's in this article



less detail


Introduction

What is Abrasive Cleaning?

Why Are Abrasive Cleaning Methods Used?

Problems of Abrasive Cleaning

Variable Factors

        Pressure

        Nonhistoric/Industrial

        Historic

How Building Materials React to Abrasive Cleaning Methods

        Brick and Architectural Terra-cotta

        Plaster and Stucco

        Building Stones

        Wood

        Metals

When is Abrasive Cleaning Permissible?

Historic Interiors that Should Not Be Cleaned Abrasively

Gentlest Means Possible

        Preparations for Cleaning

        Testing

Mitigating the Effects of Abrasive Cleaning

Summary

Selected Reading

Acknowledgements


Return to the Knowledge Base

 << Previous Page 
Viewing Page 11 of 13
Next Page >> 

Summary

Sandblasting or other abrasive methods of cleaning or paint removal are by their nature destructive to historic building materials and should not be used on historic buildings except in a few well-monitored instances. There are exceptions when certain types of abrasive cleaning may be permissible, but only if conducted by a trained conservator, and if cleaning is necessary for the preservation of the historic structure.

There is no one formula that will be suitable for cleaning all historic building surfaces. Although there are many commercial cleaning products and methods available, it is impossible to state definitively which of these will be the most effective without causing harm to the building fabric. It is often difficult to identify ingredients or their proportions contained in cleaning products; consequently it is hard to predict how a product will react to the building materials to be cleaned. Similar uncertainties affect the outcome of other cleaning methods as they are applied to historic building materials. Further advances in understanding the complex nature of the many variables of the cleaning techniques may someday provide a better and simpler solution to the problems. But until that time, the process of cleaning historic buildings must be approached with caution through trial and error.

It is important to remember that historic building materials are neither indestructible, nor are they renewable. They must be treated in a responsible manner, which may mean little or no cleaning at all if they are to be preserved for future generations to enjoy. If it is in the best interest of the building to clean it, then it should be done "using the gentlest means possible."


 << Previous Page 
Viewing Page 11 of 13
Next Page >> 



  Ads by Google

  Members:  Sign In  |  Register  |  Benefits  |  Feedback  |  Tell-a-Friend  |  Help
  Companies:  Sign In  |  Account Manager  |  Promote Your Company  |  Register  |  Help Advertise

Copyright ©2008 by Renovators, a TB Systems company. All rights reserved. Privacy policy.